Everybody loves a barbeque – Israelis and Americans on their Independence Days and other occasions in countries around the world. When did ancient hominins (precursors of humans) first use fire? (Though archaeological findings such as these appear to contradict the Biblical account of creation, which begins with God’s creation of Adam and Eve 5,782 years ago, many Chrisitan and Jewish thinkers believe that each of the Six Days of Creation were actually lengthy eras of millions of years rather than 24-hour periods, and so findings of pre-historic beginnings of life do not contradict the Biblical account of Creation.)
It is said that where there’s smoke, there’s fire. Researchers at the Weizmann Institute of Science in Rehovot are working hard to investigate that claim or at least explain what constitutes “smoke.” In an article just published in the prestigious journal PNAS, the scientists revealed an advanced, innovative method that they have developed and used to detect non-visual traces of fire dating back at least 800,000 years.
This finding, which was located in what is now Israel, was one of the earliest known pieces of evidence for the use of fire that could provide a push toward a more scientific, data-driven type of archaeology. Perhaps, more importantly, it could help us to understand better the origins of human development, our most basic traditions and our experimental and innovative nature.
The controlled use of fire by ancient hominins – a group that includes humans and some of our extinct family members – is hypothesized to date back at least a million years, to around the time that archaeologists believe Homo habilis began its transition to Homo erectus. Hominins were members of the zoological “tribe” Hominini, of which only one species exists today – Homo sapiens, or human beings. The term is used most often to refer to extinct members of the human lineage, some of which are now quite well known from fossil remains.
This discovery is no mere coincidence, as the working theory – called the “cooking hypothesis” – is that the use of fire was instrumental in our evolution, not only for allowing hominins to stay warm, make advanced tools and scare off predators but also for acquiring the ability to cook.
Cooking meat not only eliminates germs but increases efficient protein digestion and nutritional value, paving the way for the growth of the brain. The only problem with this hypothesis is a lack of data; since finding archaeological evidence of pyrotechnology primarily relies on visual identification of modifications resulting from the combustion of objects (mainly a color change), traditional methods have managed to find widespread evidence of fire use no older than 200,000 years.
While there is some evidence of fire dating back to 500,000 years ago, it remains meager, with only five archaeological sites around the world providing reliable evidence of ancient fire.
“We may have just found the sixth site,” said Dr. Filipe Natalio of Weizmann’s plant and environmental sciences department whose previous collaboration with Dr. Ido Azuri of Weizmann’s life core facilities department and colleagues provided the basis for this project.
Together they pioneered the application of artificial intelligence (AI) and spectroscopy (the study of the absorption and emission of light and other radiation by matter) in archaeology to find indications of controlled burning of stone tools dating back to between 200,000 and 420,000 years ago in Israel. Now they’re back, joined by doctoral student Zane Stepka, Dr. Liora Kolska Horwitz from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (HUJI) and Prof. Michael Chazan from the University of Toronto, Canada.
The team increased what was at stake, taking a “fishing expedition” – casting far out into the water and seeing what they could reel back in. “When we started this project,” says Natalio, “the archaeologists who have been analyzing the findings from Evron Quarry told us we wouldn’t find anything. We should have made a bet.”
The quarry, which is located in the Western Galilee, is an open-air archaeological site that was first discovered in the mid-1970s. During a series of excavations that took place at that time under the leadership of Prof. Avraham Ronen, archaeologists dug down 14 meters and uncovered a large array of animal fossils and Paleolithic tools dating back to between 800,000 and one million years ago – making it one of the oldest sites in Israel. None of the finds from the site or the soil in which they were found had any visual evidence of heat, as ash and charcoal degrade over time, eliminating the chances of finding visual evidence of burning. Therefore, if the Weizmann scientists wanted to find evidence of fire, they had to search farther afield.
The “fishing” expedition began with the development of a more advanced AI model than they had previously used. “We tested a variety of methods, among them traditional data analysis methods, machine learning modeling and more advanced deep learning models,” says Azuri, who headed the development of the models.
“The deep learning models that prevailed had a specific architecture that outperformed the others and successfully gave us the confidence we needed to further use this tool in an archaeological context having no visual signs of fire use.” The advantage of AI is that it can find hidden patterns across a multitude of scales. By pinpointing the chemical composition of materials down to the molecular level, the output of the model can estimate the temperature to which the stone tools were heated, ultimately providing information about past human behaviors.
With an accurate AI method available, the team could start fishing for molecular signals from the stone tools used by the inhabitants of the Evron Quarry almost a million years ago. To this end, the team assessed the heat exposure of 26 flint tools found at the site almost 50 years ago. The results revealed that the tools had been heated to a wide range of temperatures – some exceeding 600°Celsius. In addition, using a different spectroscopic technique, they analyzed 87 animals remains and discovered that the tusk of an extinct elephant also exhibited structural changes resulting from heating. While cautious in their claim, the presence of hidden heat suggests that our ancient ancestors, not unlike the scientists themselves, were experimentalists.
According to the research team, by looking at the archaeology from a different perspective and using new tools, they could find much more than they first thought. The methods they’ve developed could be applied, for example, at other Lower Paleolithic sites to identify non-visual evidence of fire use. In addition, this method could perhaps offer a renewed spatiotemporal perspective on the origins and controlled use of fire, helping us to better understand how hominin’s pyrotechnology-related behaviors evolved and drove other behaviors.
“Especially in the case of early fire,” added Stepka, “if we use this method at archaeological sites that are one or two million years old, we might learn something new.”
By all accounts, their work was a resounding success. “It was not only a demonstration of exploration and being rewarded in terms of the knowledge gained,” concluded Natalio, “but of the potential that lies in combining different disciplines. Ido has a background in quantum chemistry; Zane is a scientific archaeologis; and Liora and Michael are prehistorians. By working together, we have learned from each other. For me, it’s a demonstration of how scientific research across the humanities and science should work.”